Friday, 09 November 2012 09:38

Disturbing footage from WW1 reveals effects of shell shock on soldiers

    ABOVE: Shocking: In a disturbing video released by British Pathe, a semi-naked solider at Seale Hayne hospital can be seen falling to the floor in a fit after shaking and staggering around the stark, bare room

    Uncontrollable shaking, terrifying nightmares and severe convulsions

    These were among the most devastating symptoms suffered by the many First World War soldiers who suffered shell shock. By the end of the war, more than 80,000 men who had endured the horrors of battle were struggling to return to normality.

    war neuroses victims received little sympathy

    Suffering: At the time, most war neuroses victims received little sympathy or much care and often endured more trauma with treatments such as electric shock therapy and solitary confinement

    And here, disturbing footage compiled by British Pathé film archivists and released to MailOnline today, brings home the terrifying reality that for many the war never really ended. At the time, most shell shock victims were treated harshly and with little sympathy as their symptoms were not understood and they were seen as a sign of weakness.

    But at Newton Abbott's Seale Hayne in Devon, the approach was very different due to the revolutionary approach of a doctor called Arthur Hurst, an army major, who believed he could cure every shell shock victim.

    Private Eagerfield diagnosed as having war hyperthyroidism and hyperadrenalism

    Treatment: Private Eagerfield diagnosed as having war hyperthyroidism and hyperadrenalism. Eagerfield's facial expression is also typical of von Graefe's sign where there is an immobility of the upper eyelid and downward rotation of the eye

    In several medical establishments instead of receiving proper care, many victims endured more trauma with treatments such as solitary confinement or electric shock therapy. But at the military hospital, deep in the Devon countryside, Mr Hurst used treatments such as hypnosis, persuasion, massage and dietary treatments to cure his patients.

    His miracle treatments meant that he was able to cure 90 percent of shell shocked soldiers in just one session. In a disturbing video released by British Pathe, a semi-naked solider at Seale Hayne hospital can be seen falling to the floor in a fit after shaking and staggering around the stark, bare room.

    But after treatment, the man is seen wearing his uniform marching confidently towards the camera. Mr Hurst encouraged his patients to shoot and also staged a reconstruction of the battlefields of Flanders on Dartmoor to help the men relive their experiences.

    Swaying and nose wiping tic

    Swaying and nose wiping tic: Private Read, aged 32 was buried by a shell in August 1917. When he arrived at the hospital, he had an hysterical swaying moving problem and a constant nose wiping tic. It took just two hours of treatment for the twitches to disappear and for Read to be able to walk correctly

    On the wards the men were encouraged to write and to produce a magazine with a gossip column called Ward Whispers. 'The main work was occupational therapy,' explained Arthur's son Christopher to the BBC. 'These solders who had been shell shocked had lost vital faculties like walking and speaking.

    'They were given jobs to do and this was interspersed with intensive therapy sessions,' said Christopher. 'My father was the guiding genius here and he cured these cases by means of persuasion and hypnotism.'

    Private Preston aged 19 had amnesia

    Terrified: Private Preston, aged 19, had amnesia, word blindness and word deafness except to the word 'Bombs!'. Here Preston is emerging from underneath the bed after cowering underneath it

    The term shell shock was coined, in 1917, by a medical officer called Charles Myers - it was also known as 'war neurosis', 'combat stress' and Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. At first shell shock was thought to be caused by soldiers being exposed to exploding shells.

    Arthur Hurst was ahead of his time

    New approach: One doctor called Arthur Hurst was ahead of his time and believed he could cure every shell shock victim using revolutionary treatments such as hypnosis, persuasion, massage and dietary treatments

    But doctors couldn't find any physical damage to explain the symptoms and medical staff started to realise that there were deeper causes. Doctors soon found that many men suffering the symptoms of shell shock without having even been in the front lines.

    Private Bradshaw was buried in the trenches in 1916

    Recovery: Private Bradshaw was buried in the trenches in 1916. He was left completely paraplegic for two months after. He was taught to move his legs whilst lying down and then to get up and walk around. After a few hours or re-education, he was cured

    Source: Daily Mail

    Related World War History Online Posts

    • Who was the Florence Nightingale of WW1? Injured soldiers drew pictures of ‘pretty face’ and gave thanks for caring touch of Nurse McDonald
      Who was the Florence Nightingale of WW1? Injured soldiers drew pictures of ‘pretty face’ and gave thanks for caring touch of Nurse McDonald A moving scrapbook from a World War One hospital in which patients wrote their thanks to a 'Nurse McDonald' has emerged after nearly 100 years. The men were recuperating at the Passmore Edwards Hospital in Willesden, London, between April 1916 and June 1917, when they made their entries. The soldiers wrote poems, drew pictures and penned their praise to the…
    • A war that changed us all - The First World War
      A war that changed us all - The First World War The very last combat veteran of the First World War, Claude “Chuckles” Choules of the Royal Navy, died in an Australian nursing home last year, aged 110. The last non-combat veteran, Florence Green, an RAF steward, died this February in King’s Lynn, also aged 110 So the First World War has almost entirely deserted living memory. And yet its memory…
    • Perfectly Preserved: 21 German soldiers found entombed in a World War One shelter
      Perfectly Preserved: 21 German soldiers found entombed in a World War One shelter Twenty-one German soldiers entombed in a perfectly preserved World War One shelter have been discovered 94 years after they were killed. The men were part of a larger group of 34 who were buried alive when a huge Allied shell exploded above the tunnel, near the small town of Carspach in the Alsace region in France, in 1918 causing it…
    • WW1 Croydon soldier's life told as part of exhibition
      WW1 Croydon soldier's life told as part of exhibition The story of a soldier missing in action and a father who never gave up hope will be told in an exhibition dedicated to those lost in the Battle of the Somme. Charles Waller of Warrington Road, Croydon, was 22 when he marched into no-man’s land on July 1, 1916. He and around 20,000 others from the British Army never…