Sunday, 28 October 2012 00:32

Bomber Command – Australians in World War II - Book Review

    In June the Australian Government’s Department of Veterans’ Affairs released a book called Bomber Command: Australians in World War II

    Launched at the Australian War Memorial in the presence of three Bomber Command veterans, it’s DVA’s second book in a series looking at Australians and their experiences in World War II (the first looked at Greece and Crete). Dr Richard Reid, of the Department’s Commemorations Branch, was the author (though interestingly he is not credited on the front cover). A couple of weeks after the launch DVA gave a copy of the book to each of the Australian veterans who went to London for the opening of the Bomber Command memorial.

    The first half of the book contains an overview of Australia’s role in Bomber Command. Starting with a description of a raid over Berlin, it goes on to cover in some detail the typical path followed by many aircrew, from enlistment to training and right through to their operational squadrons.

    Reid makes good use of the Australians at War Film Archive (another DVA project in which he was involved) among other resources, to build a picture of ‘what it was like’, with a focus on individual Australian airmen. Unfortunately, though a well-respected and experienced military historian, Reid is not a Bomber Command specialist, and in places it shows. For example, on p. 150 he mistakenly calls the Avro Manchester the “prototype” of the Lancaster. While the Lanc was indeed a development of the Manchester, the final product was an entirely different aircraft – ergo, not a prototype.

    There are also some editing errors (which I admit may not be the historian’s fault): throughout the text, altitudes are converted to metres, an annoying move that betrays a fundamental misunderstanding of technical terminology (in the Western world altitudes are and have always been measured in feet, regardless of whether the country uses metric measurements elsewhere). And, unforgivably, the airfield from which the Dambusters took off on the Dams raid is misspelt as ‘Scrampton’ and, on at least two occasions, the name of Britain’s first four-engined heavy bomber is misspelt as ‘Sterling’. Though minor errors in isolation, they all add up to an overall impression of a certain amount of ‘slapdashery’.

    But then you reach the imagery. The entire second half of the book is taken up by a rather impressive collection of photos and other artwork, mostly taken from the Australian War Memorial’s collections. And this part of the book is very good.

    There are the obligatory photos that everyone has seen before (like the one of S-Sugar being bombed up at Waddington) but there are also many that are more unusual. They cover the entire journey through Bomber Command: enlistment, training, operations and homecoming (or, for those less fortunate, burial and remembrance). It’s a good collection, reproduced in high quality and with informative and comprehensive captions.

    According to the press release that accompanied the launch, the book is “an invaluable resource, helping Australians learn about the important history of Bomber Command, including stories of those who served and died”.

    I’d agree with almost all of that. It will certainly make many of the stories of Bomber Command more accessible to Australians in the future – and in that sense, the Department have achieved something worthwhile – but it can only be an ‘invaluable resource’ if its facts are correct. Being a Government publication, it can be seen as an official record of what happened, and therefore it needs to be done right. Their hearts were in the right place, but unfortunately it would appear that those who produced this book settled for merely ‘close enough for government work’.

    Bomber Command: Australians in World War II – which is, if you can look past its problems, still worth a look simply because of the images.

    Source: Reviews

    Related World War History Online Posts

    • Soldaten: On Fighting, Killing and Dying – Book Review
      Soldaten: On Fighting, Killing and Dying – Book Review Historians often dream of being able to eavesdrop on history, but few can hope to obtain such spectacularly direct access as that presented in this major addition to the literature on the second world war. Discovered in 2001 by the historian Sönke Neitzel, the transcripts of conversations between German prisoners of war, secretly recorded by the British and American intelligence…
    • Bomber Command – Australians in World War II - Book Review
      Bomber Command – Australians in World War II - Book Review In June the Australian Government’s Department of Veterans’ Affairs released a book called Bomber Command: Australians in World War II Launched at the Australian War Memorial in the presence of three Bomber Command veterans, it’s DVA’s second book in a series looking at Australians and their experiences in World War II (the first looked at Greece and Crete). Dr Richard…
    • ‘Deliver Us From Darkness’ tells the continuing story of the 3rd Battalion, 506th Parachute Infantry Regiment during the invasion of Holland.
      ‘Deliver Us From Darkness’ tells the continuing story of the 3rd Battalion, 506th Parachute Infantry Regiment during the invasion of Holland. “Military historians have said ‘Market Garden’ was a total disaster. Try telling that to the Dutch, for whom US & Allied paratroopers were liberators from German tyranny and occupation. Ian Gardner takes readers through the story battle by battle, magnificently, just as he did in his previous book on the battle of Normandy – Tonight We Die As Men.” Ed…
    • Desert Battles of World War II - DVD Review
      Desert Battles of World War II - DVD Review If you are looking for a DVD about World War II in North Africa then this has got to be one of the best, all-round documentary out at the moment. Marvelous footage and clear narration take you through the whys and wherefores of the desert war, and follows the ups and downs of both the Allied and Axis forces as…